A witness told investigators that Bustos had been involved in at least one similar robbery before, Ray told The Post.

dating boston prostitutes-54dating boston prostitutes-39dating boston prostitutes-37

In rare instances, victims - like Hilarie - can lose their lives.

Still, stories exist across the country of people looking for love but finding violent criminals instead.

That same month, a 36-year-old man was robbed in Ohio after getting together with a woman he met on Plenty Of Fish, according to

As the victim escorted the woman known as "Nikki" to his car, a man with a gun appeared and the pair robbed the victim of $300, then ran away.

The brothers had talked about the site, because Jackson is also a member.

"Half of the profiles, they don't even put their real name," Jackson said.

He'd picked her up and they went bowling in Winter Haven, Fla., at Cypress Lanes, which offers shoe and lane rentals for a quarter on Thursday nights, and specials on pizza and beer.

A few hours later, the pair ended up at his place, where they talked a bit more and met up with his roommate. Bustos sent the single father a text afterward: She'd had a good time, she wrote to Hilarie, and wanted to meet up the following night at his place.

At a news conference, he said he suspected she was experienced with the scheme.